It’s time to move on from the Good Place — and we’re not just talking about the afterlife. The beloved comedy created by Michael Schur, The Good Place, is officially exiting Netflix, leaving fans to scramble for alternatives. This isn’t just a plot twist for the show’s characters; it’s a real-life dilemma for viewers who love the show’s sharp writing and heartwarming humor. But here’s where it gets controversial: Why wasn’t Peacock the obvious destination for this NBC gem? And what does that mean for fans who’ve been waiting for a new home?
Originally airing on NBC from 2016 to 2020, The Good Place was a standout sitcom known for its clever twists, stellar cast, and deep philosophical themes. Led by Kristen Bell and Ted Danson, the show followed a quirky afterlife where characters had to navigate moral dilemmas to earn their place in the ‘Good’ realm. The ensemble cast — William Jackson Harper, Jameela Jamil, D’Arcy Carden, and Manny Jacinto — delivered standout performances that made the show a cultural phenomenon. If you haven’t seen it, think of it as a 53-episode binge worth every minute (each episode clocks in at 22 minutes).
One of the show’s most iconic lines comes from Eleanor Shellstrop: ‘I’ve only ever said I love you to two men my entire life: Stone Cold Steve Austin, and a guy in a dark club… who I mistook for Stone Cold Steve Austin.’ This line perfectly captures the show’s blend of absurd humor and heartfelt moments. But let’s get back to the main issue: Where can you stream The Good Place now that it’s leaving Netflix?
The last day to watch the show on Netflix is September 25, so if you’re still relying on that platform, you’ll need to act fast. Unfortunately, the series won’t be available on Hulu or HBO Max — at least not right now. And while you might have guessed Peacock (the NBCUniversal-owned streaming service), the answer is no. The show won’t be added to Peacock in October, which has left fans wondering if this is a missed opportunity.
But here’s some good news: All four seasons of The Good Place will be available on Amazon Prime Video starting September 26. That’s a relief for fans who want to continue their binge without jumping through hoops. Amazon Prime costs $14.99/month (or $139/year), and a standalone Prime Video membership is also an option for $8.99/month. For students, Amazon offers a discounted rate of $7.49/month, and qualifying government assistance recipients (like EBT, Medicaid, or SNAP) can get it for just $6.99/month. Oh, and if you’re curious, Prime Video does offer a 30-day free trial — perfect for testing the waters before committing.
So, what’s the takeaway? The Good Place is leaving Netflix, but its legacy is far from over. Whether it’s on Prime Video or another platform, the show’s humor, wit, and moral questions will continue to resonate. And this is the part most people miss: The show’s ability to make you laugh while making you think. What do you think? Should The Good Place have stayed on Netflix, or was moving to Prime Video the right move? Share your thoughts in the comments — we’d love to hear your take!
